NATCHITOCHES, La. -- A 10-month criminal investigation has ended with the arrests of a couple in connection with the theft of more than $156,000 from Ashland Baptist Church in Ashland, according to Natchitoches Parish Sheriff Stuart Wright.
The investigation began in February when members of Ashland Baptist Church contacted the Natchitoches Parish Sheriff’s Office requesting an investigation into discrepancies and alleged missing funds.
Deputies completed an initial offense report and turned the case over to the NPSO Criminal Investigations Bureau for further investigation.
Over the next several months, detectives worked closely with church and bank officials, conducted interviews, executed search warrants, and meticulously reviewed financial records and audits.
As the investigation progressed, with the full cooperation of church officials, detectives learned that a church deacon, identified as Troy R. Wamsley, and his wife, appointed church treasurer Mandy L. Wamsley, both of Chestnut, allegedly wrote and cashed more than 100 unauthorized checks made payable to cash.
Detectives also learned the Wamsleys allegedly admitted to taking the funds during a meeting with church officials and requested an opportunity to repay the money.
Detectives say the extensive nature of the financial records required several months to complete the investigation while also continuing work on other criminal cases.
Upon establishing sufficient evidence and probable cause, detectives obtained arrest warrants signed by a 10th Judicial District Court judge.
The couple was arrested Tuesday.
Troy Wamsley, 71, and Mandy Wamsley, 58, were booked into the LaSalle Corrections/Natchitoches Parish Detention Center each on a felony theft over $25,000. Both are free on bonds of $10,000.
“This was a complex and lengthy financial investigation that required patience, cooperation, and a detailed review of records. I commend our detectives for their persistence and professionalism throughout this case. When individuals are entrusted with financial responsibilities, especially within a place of worship, that trust must be honored. We appreciate the cooperation of the church and bank officials, and we will continue to pursue justice while ensuring accountability under the law," Wright said.